Guildmaster Sues for Return of LampsDecember 27, 2012
Furniture and accent vendor GuildMaster has filed suit in U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Western District of Missouri for the return of 5,150 lamps manufactured and shipped a year ago.
A federal indictment calls for forfeiture and destruction of the lamps, which GuildMaster has valued at $900,000 and the government has valued at $1.9 million.
The GuildMaster suit is part of the petition for Chapter 11 Reorganization filed on Dec. 13. On Dec. 12, the company was served a federal indictment on nine counts related to the December 2011 shipments of lamps bearing a removable, unlicensed sticker indicating a UL trademark, which was applied without the knowledge or approval of GuildMaster’s U.S. management team. The lamps were manufactured by Dongguan Yangming Hardware Crafts Limited, a lamp factory purchased by GuildMaster in November 2011.
“The employees of the Chinese plant decided indiscriminately and incorrectly – without U.S. personnel or U.S. management knowledge – that the lamps needed to have the UL-certified stickers on them,” says Steve Crowder, CEO of GuildMaster, Springfield, Mo. “We first learned of the offending stickers on January 27, 2012, the day after the seizure and immediately agreed that the removable stickers should not be on the lamps and had the stickers removed and destroyed in China.”
GuildMaster said the lamps are constructed of UL-certified components and the safety of the lamps was never in question. The stickers are considered counterfeit because GuildMaster does not hold a license for UL-certified lamps.
“The basis for this motion to return the lamps is that the seized lamps are property of the 'estate' under bankruptcy code and that because removing the sticker eliminates the issue, the lamps should be returned to GuildMaster to sell in order to pay our debtors under bankruptcy protection," Crowder said. "Since the seizure we have manufactured and shipped thousands of lamps--sans the counterfeit stickers--with no further audits or government inspections. It makes no sense to destroy the lamps when removing the stickers solves the problem.”
The suit filed by GuildMaster includes motions to: the right for GuildMaster to inspect all of the lamps to clarify whether all of the lamps actually bear the counterfeit stickers and therefore were seized improperly; and return of the 5,150 lamps after the stickers are removed to GuildMaster for sale to its customers.